7 minutes read
Questions to ask a Shopify agency
Which questions to ask a Shopify agency about its proof, who controls your store after launch and what the project includes, and what a good answer sounds like.

Shopify’s Partner Directory lets you filter agencies by services, industry, location and price range, and sort them by average rating or price. Those filters narrow the list, but they don’t tell you who will build your store or who controls it after launch.
Shopify’s partner program also places agencies in tiers, from Select to Platinum, based on performance. A tier shows an agency’s standing with Shopify, but it doesn’t show how quickly your team can change the store after launch or what the project includes.
The agencies worth hiring answer those questions with names, documents and dates, and say plainly when a project isn’t a fit. This guide covers nine questions to ask, what a good answer sounds like, and the warning signs to listen for.
What should you ask a Shopify agency before you hire it?
Ask a Shopify agency for proof from stores like yours, a clear answer on who controls the code and your Shopify admin, and a written scope, timeline and app list. Use these nine questions, and compare each answer with what a good one sounds like:
| Question | A good answer | A warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Have you built stores like mine? | Two or three live stores in your category | Logos with no live links |
| What did those stores gain? | A number, a change and a time frame | “Better design” with no figures |
| Who will work on my store? | A named designer, developer and project lead | “Our team”, with no names |
| Who controls the code? | Code you can read, and terms on what you own | No answer on ownership |
| Who has access to my admin? | A collaborator account you can remove | A request for your owner login |
| What can my team change alone? | Pages, sections and products in the editor | Every change is a ticket |
| What does the scope include? | A written list of deliverables | One line item for “the build” |
| How long will it take? | Dated milestones | A range with no milestones |
| Which apps will I need? | A list with monthly fees | “We’ll decide during development” |
If an agency gives a vague answer to any row, ask for it in writing before you sign.
The scope changes with the project. A Shopify replatform, such as a move from WooCommerce, adds data migration and URL redirects to it. A theme your store has outgrown usually calls for a rebuild instead.
What proof should an agency show you?
An agency should show you live stores like yours, the results those stores saw, and a client you can call.
Have you built stores like mine?
Ask for two or three live stores in your category, and open them on your phone before the call. A supplement brand with subscriptions needs different things from a furniture store with a large catalog. The examples should match your catalog, your sales model and your size. Then ask what the agency changed on each store and why.
What did those stores gain?
A good answer ties a number to a specific change and a time frame. Kaged, a sports nutrition brand, saw its conversion rate rise 45.27%, comparing September 2023 on its new Platter store with September 2022 before it. Ask who measured each number: TileCloud’s speed score of about 9 rose to 81 in Shopify’s own report, according to its case study.
Then ask for a reference from a client whose store has been live for at least a year. In Shopify’s Partner Directory, merchants rate an agency’s quality of work and communication as separate star ratings. Shopify requests those reviews from merchants who worked with the agency through collaborator access.
Who builds your store, and who controls it afterward?
Your agency should name the people who build your store and leave you in control of the code and your Shopify admin after launch.
Who will work on my store?
Ask for the name and role of the designer, developer and project lead on your project, and whether each is an employee or a contractor. A senior person can sell a project and then hand it to a team you never meet. Ask to meet the team before you sign. A good agency also tells you who to call when something breaks after launch.
Who controls the code?
An outside agency ran Ministry of Supply’s headless store and controlled the codebase. A change as small as a button style took about a month. After it moved to a Shopify theme built by Platter, its team handled 95% of site changes itself, according to its case study.
Ask where your theme code lives, whether you can read it, and what happens to it if you leave. If the agency builds on its own framework, ask which parts you own and which you license, and get the answer in the contract.
Who has access to my admin?
Shopify’s collaborator accounts let an agency request access to your store. You choose which permissions to grant before you accept. You can remove the account later in Settings > Users and permissions, and it doesn’t count toward your staff account limit.
Give the agency a collaborator account instead of your owner login. Ask it to build in a duplicate of your theme and publish only after you’ve reviewed it.
How fast can your team change the store after launch?
Your team should be able to change pages, sections and products without a developer, and the agency should tell you which changes still need one.
What can my team change alone?
Every Man Jack’s agency-run store needed a developer for changes, and simple updates could take over a month. After it moved to Platter, changes that took weeks took hours or less, according to its case study. At The Absorption Company, content lives in metafields, so its team ships new pages and products without a developer.
Ask the agency to show you in the theme editor how you would add a landing page, swap a banner and edit a product page. Then ask what support follows launch. Our Improve retainer starts at $8,000 a month and includes weekly performance updates. It has a three-month minimum and a 30-day out clause.
What should the proposal include?
A Shopify agency’s proposal should include a written scope, dated milestones and a list of the apps your store will need.
What does the scope include?
Ask for the deliverables in writing: design, development, integrations, testing and a hand-off with documentation. Our builds cover strategy, design, development, integrations, QA and a hand-off with documentation, and we scope each one by complexity, migration needs and design.
Also ask what happens to changes after design approval. At Platter, they may need additional work, so ask every agency how it prices them.
How long will it take?
Ask for dated milestones for design approval, development, testing and launch. Gainful moved from a custom React and Django stack to Shopify in under 90 days, and Big Blanket rebuilt its storefront in 16 business days. Most of our builds finish in 150 days or less, depending on complexity, and we map out the timeline before we begin.
Which apps will I need?
Ask for a list of every app the store will need, with what each one does and its monthly fee. Wild Earth’s storefront used up to 15 third-party apps, each with its own integrations and customer service team, according to its case study.
A good agency says which features come built into the theme and which need an app. That lets you add the monthly fees to the cost of the project. If you’re comparing proposals, request a free Shopify store audit and we’ll review your app stack and tell you what to keep, replace or remove.
Frequently asked questions
Does a Shopify Platinum Partner badge mean an agency is the right choice?
No, a partner tier doesn’t tell you whether an agency fits your store. Shopify places agencies in tiers from Select to Platinum based on performance. You still need to check the stores the agency built, who will work on yours and what happens after launch.
How does a Shopify agency bill you?
A Shopify agency bills you directly, not through your Shopify subscription. Ask for a payment schedule tied to milestones in the proposal, so each payment follows a deliverable you’ve reviewed.
What should a Shopify agency contract include?
A Shopify agency contract should state the deliverables, the milestone dates and who owns the code and design files. It should also say how and when you pay and how either side can end the engagement. For ongoing work, check the minimum term and the notice period. Ours are three months and 30 days.
Do you need Shopify Plus to hire an agency?
No, you don’t need Shopify Plus to hire an agency. Agencies work with stores on both standard and Plus plans, and Platter does too, as long as the store foundation supports improvement.
Can you start with a smaller project before a full rebuild?
Yes, you can start with a smaller engagement. Some brands begin with ongoing improvements and later decide to rebuild, while others rebuild first and then move into a retainer.
Create a more profitable store
Get strategies, tactics, and insights from the 200+ Shopify stores we've built, delivered to your inbox every week.
That didn't go through. Check your connection and try again.
Continue reading

How long does a Shopify build take?

WooCommerce vs Shopify: when should a growing brand switch?

Shopify Advanced vs Plus: what Plus adds and what it costs

How long does a Shopify build take?

WooCommerce vs Shopify: when should a growing brand switch?
